5 Jul
Women in Chains and the Scandal of Ultra-Orthodoxy’s Indifference
It began when Susan Zinkin divorced her husband in 1962, but little did she realize she would be a “bound woman” forbidden to marry for the next 50 years of her life because her husband refused to grant her a religious divorce. Hence, she became a “chained wife” under Jewish law until her husband died 50 years later. Now, at age 73, Ms Zinkin, a retired Orthodox Jewish teacher from north London, divorced Israel Errol Elias in Britain’s spoke of her relief at finally being freed from her status as the world’s longest-serving “chained wife.”
“As awful as it may sound my ex-husband’s death is a great relief and a huge weight off my shoulders – to be stuck like that was so cruel,” she said yesterday in an interview with The Independent. “I’m quite convinced that had the rabbis wanted to get their act together they could have done something within Jewish law and found a solution.”
Of course they could have done many things, e.g., haf’ka’at kiddushin, better known as annulment. It’s a method that has been practiced for 1700 years-but the conservatism of today’s ultra-Orthodox rabbis prevent them from utilizing this time-honored method of dissolving a bad marriage like Ms. Zinkin’s.
Despite efforts to shame him, nothing worked, in fact the protests only seemed to strengthen his resolve. The outcry for justice went with no rabbinic response, they were too powerless to do anything.
Speaking from her home in Kfar Saba, near Tel Aviv, Ms Zinkin called on Britain’s network of beth dins (Jewish courts) to do more to help chained women and to speak out against husbands who refuse to grant divorces. “The Jewish religious authorities come together to talk about and solve all sorts of religious and social problems but they never seem to get around to discussing [agunahs],” she said. “It is time they did.”
Here’s the worst part of it. Ms Zinkin, feared that her children would be stigmatized if she remarried. Her children – and any of her future offspring – would also be shunned as mamzers, a halakhic term to describe the offspring of adulterous or incestuous relationships. “That’s a terrible stigma for the child,” she explained. “They’re illegitimate for Jewish purposes and I just couldn’t do that to any child of mine. Even Jews who aren’t very religious wouldn’t necessarily want to marry someone and have children born with mamzer status.”
For the first time in her adult life, Ms Zinkin is free.