28 Aug
Recognizing Israel’s True Friends: Kudos to Glenn Beck
Over the last several years, radio host Glenn Beck has become quite a media sensation. I began listening to his program about five years ago and always regarded him as an articulate friend of Israel. Mind you, many of my colleagues see him as a religious fanatic. Yet, at a time when Israel is struggling for respectability in a world that is so blatantly anti-Semitic, trust me—Glenn Beck is a refreshing change, especially when you compare him to the daily pundits found in European societies, where it is still fashionable as ever to blame the Jews for all the world’s problems. Yes, I said, “blame the Jews,” because we are still the world’s favorite scapegoat. Some traditions die hard in the world but today anti-Semitism has taken on a new clever guise. Instead of openly espousing anti-Semitism, it has fostered “anti-Zionism.” Of course, in the Nazi-esque mentality of the Muslim suicide-bomber, every Jew is in the final analysis—a Zionist.
Unfortunately, that’s not really true either. Strange as it may sound, there is a chorus of Jewish intellectuals and rabbis, who routinely argue that if Israel gave up all the “Occupied territories,” then there would be peace. How stupid can we be? The prophet Isaiah sometimes likened Israel to the most picturesque metaphor:
The ox knows its owner,
and the donkey its master’s crib;
but Israel does not know,
my people do not understand.
Isaiah 1:3
It doesn’t matter how many missiles Hamas and Hezbollah shoot into Israeli cities. The “civilized” world always blames Israel for defending her people. When a reporter asked Mahatma Gandhi what he thought of “Western Civilization,” he replied, “I think it would be a good idea.” Well, I personally think that “Western Civilization” with respect to its treatment of the Jewish people is an oxymoron. There is nothing “civilized” about Europe’s treatment of the Jews. Their societal and religious hatred of our people runs like a stream of consciousness and is still firmly embedded in their psyche.
However, Europe is not alone. There are American leaders that tend to think like Europe whenever it pertains to Israel and the Jews. Take President Obama for an example. Jews love it when he says how much the United States values Israel as a friend, and yet—without missing a heartbeat—Obama then tells Israel they need to make the new proposed Palestinian state contiguous, even though that will mean that Israel will lose its territorial integrity. Unlike any American President of the past, Obama declares the old Jewish quarter of Jerusalem as, “occupied.” Like a trained chimpanzee, liberal American Jews accept the President’s words without a criticism.
According to these misleaders, Israel should merely accept the promise that Palestinians want to live in “peace.” Maybe Israel and their American Jewish cousins should purchase a bridge in Brooklyn too. Palestinians don’t even have Israel on their map; nor do they teach mutual recognition in their schools. Instead, they pay homage to the cult of the Shihad; the suicide bomber is a hero every Palestinian child is taught to emulate and adore.
Of course, this reality brings to mind a famous quote from the singer Willie Nelson, “Are you going to believe what you see or what I tell you? “ Groucho Marx made a similar remark, “Who are you going to believe - me or your own eyes?” Well, the Jewish community has more often chosen to believe what our “friends” like Obama and the Europeans tell them to believe, despite the empirical proof of what we see with our own eyes.
As a child of a Holocaust survivor, I refuse to accept the platitudes these leaders offer about being Israel’s “friends.” With friends like these, who needs enemas? (pardon the pun.) For all of President Obama’s platitudes and excessive moralization, he has yet to even visit Israel. The answer is compellingly simple: In his heart, he views the State of Israel and its continued existence as a moral problem. Obama doesn’t want to give the impression that he even recognizes Israel; he stands with the likes of Iran, Syria, and Hamas-Israel is to be eliminated, if not immediately, then piecemeal.
So why do I like Glenn Beck? It’s not because of his personal theology. I really could care less about his eschatological beliefs regarding the End-times. What matters to me is more how Christians act and behave toward Israel and by this standard, Glenn Beck is a standup man worthy of our admiration and respect. When my evangelical friends flew to Israel to stand by Israel during its war with Hezbollah, every Jew knew in Israel who our “real” friends are and guess what, it’s not the Presbyterians, or the Methodists, or the other mainline churches that demonize Israel.
Consider some of Beck’s comments:
“The grand councils of the earth condemn Israel. Across the border, Syria slaughters its own citizens. The grand councils are silent…
Note that the President has been exceptionally tight-lipped about Assad and until just a few months ago, regarded Assad as a viable “peace partner” for Israel. How foolish can one possibly be? “Who are you going to believe - me or your own eyes?” When the people of Iran a few years ago challenged the Mullahs of Iran, President Obama did nothing, and said nothing. In his mind, Iran is a country that is happy to be under the watchful eye of the Mullahs. President Obama enables thugocracies.
Some of Beck’s other comments are equally noteworthy:
“These international councils, these panels of so-called diplomats, condemn Israel not because they believe Israel needs to be corrected. They do so because it is convenient.”
No kidding, Glenn.
“The diplomats are afraid, and so they submit. They surrender to falsehood. The truth matters not. To the keepers of conventional wisdom, a sacrifice of the truth is a small price to pay. What difference does it make if we beat up on little Israel? These are the actions of the fearful and cowards.”
Glenn Beck hit a home run and his words resonate with Hillel’s, “If I am not for myself, who will be for me?” It’s time we start waking up to this reality and tell our “friends” in the White House that we will not stand for their hypocrisy.
Posted by SK on 28.08.11 at 5:12 am
A mouses uses a fox to its advantage at its peril.
It is nice that you have no concerns about “eschatological beliefs” and that you are willing to overlook the ultimate fate of the Jewish people in Beck’s ideology. It’s nice, but it is not how most American Jews feel, and with good reason. We know that anyone who believes that the world is about to end and take all the Jews with it is not our friend, even if he supports the State of Israel without question.
We are Jews — we worship none but G-d. This means that we do not worship nor are we required to support any specific political party currently operating in the modern State of Israel. Those who threaten Israel’s democratic institutions are just as dangerous to its survival as those who do not care about terrorist attacks. Does Beck support Israel or only its right-wing? Does he support democracy or only the settlements? Is he concerned about the welfare of the Jewish people or only about forcing the hand of G-d to do his will?
Why would you trust anyone who believes that the world will end in his lifetime? Much less a person who negates all other American Jewish beliefs and values in his domestic agenda? Does this person plan for the future? Will he care about schools and roads and the First Amendment if the world is about to end?
How many American children will die without health care and how many Israeli soldiers will die to defend settlements so that Beck can have his Messiah on his timeline? I would go to Israel myself and take up arms to defend its security but I will not see another one of my friend’s children die to defend a non-democratic state in all of the land.
If someone says that they support Israel’s security but not its democratic institutions, I call that person a traitor to Zionism. I’m sorry to be harsh, but that is the truth as I see it. Christian conservatives do not share our values and they are *not* our friends. If Beck is your friend, I urge you to seek better company.
Posted by admin on 28.08.11 at 5:12 am
Dear SK,
Thank you for your thoughtful letter. While we have our differences, I always appreciate listening to contrarian perspectives; indeed, dialogue enables people to expand their understanding of the world and the events that continue to shape our collective lives.
That being said, I cannot address all the issues because of time factors and other commitments since this is a busy time of the year for rabbis, who must prepare themselves for the High Holidays.
The point regarding eschatological beliefs is by no means limited to Glenn Beck; it really applies to all Christian, Muslim, Hindu, Buddhist, Janist, animist (and so on . . .) belief systems regarding the hereafter. While we differ with traditional Christian view, this does not mean we should ignore dialoguing with non-Jews; this is all the more so with the Muslim and Christian faiths, which bear a family resemblance in many ways to our own. Yet, there are many differences.
Evangelical Christians risked their lives to save Jews during the Holocaust (e.g., Corrie Ten Boom and her family, saving hundreds of Jews who were being hunted by the Nazis. She did this because of her belief that if the Christians wished to be blessed, they need to be supportive and loving toward Israel. Many evangelical Christians I know (including Glen Beck) strongly base their theology on Genesis 12ff regarding the Abrahamic blessings.
Contrary to your insinuations, Israel is a democracy and it is the ONLY democracy in the Arab world where Arabs can freely express themselves in government and in the media. Most Arabs living in Jerusalem prefer to live under Israeli control rather than PLO because the latter is so capricious and corrupt.
Israel has given back the lion-share of the West Bank and has helped Palestinians out in countless ways. They co-exist for the most part as friends, but it is absurd to expect or demand that Israel give back every centimeter of land conquered. If Israel really wanted to keep ALL the land, in my opinion they would have been justified given the terrorist threat that looms against them.
Wrt to American financial support, unlike Egypt which receives almost as much money as Israel, Israel has paid every dollar back. Your friend Obama recently forgave Egypt of over 1.5 billion dollars at a time when our country can ill afford losing any more money.
When you use the term, “right wing,” you really need to define your terms. Who are you referring to? Wrt Beck’s other beliefs, I purposely focused on some of the issues. We do not agree with him on other issues, so what? Are you suggesting that everyone agree on everything? That’s fine for a totalitarian state, and make no mistake: a totalitarian state can be “liberal” as much as it can be fascist.
Israel has democratic issues with respect to the Ultra-Orthodox and Chabad, i.e., religious pluralism. But the US has its problems as well and is not a perfect democracy. Most Israelis (with the exception of the Neturei Karta) support Israel’s democratic institutions.
After everything is said and done, I believe you ignored the substance of my article. Obama is no friend of Israel-period and neither are the rest of his anti-Zionist gang. Beck may not be perfect, but compared to Obama-Beck is a saint! Obama has done more than any American president to destabilize our allies in the Middle East. Even as we speak, Al Qaeda is expanding its influence in war-ravaged Libya. Egypt in all likelihood will rescind the peace treaty it made with Israel. Why? Because we have a neophyte who doesn’t understand anything about the geopolitical currents that govern the Middle East. If you thought Bush was bad, Obama is far worse!